Circumcision and Hygiene in
Geriatric Patients
According to the author, Ruth Frank,
the information provided to parents when making the decision about
circumcision is inadequate "because it does not address the
question of what happens if that person is unable to care for
himself. The geriatrics community has had little say and no
input into the information that is presented to parents
at the time they are deciding whether to circumcise their
infant sons, yet the result is of this decision is played out
daily in nursing homes, long-term care facilities, and
in the homes of caregivers."
 
Because the geriatrics community has to deal with caring
for those who can no longer look after themselves,
the issue to circumcise "is as much
a geriatrics issue as a pediatric one". The author also
points out the difficulties involved (both physical
and emotional) in performing hygienic care in
the case of uncircumcised older patient:
"Frequently, the patient misinterprets the care and
strikes out in terror, kicking and scratching caregivers,
whether family of nursing staff". Family members
also often complain that their efforts are interpreted
as an invitation for sexual activity. As a result,
they often don't even try to keep the patient clean.
 
The problem of caring for uncircumcised older patients
is becoming worse due to the fact that the general
population is aging, with a bigger portion of the
population living longer and longer.
 
In the light of these arguments, the author
"strongly suggests that Officers of the American Geriatric
Society put the issue on their aggenda for discussion and
also that they approach Officers of the American Pediatric
Society to re-examine their circumcision policy".
R. Frank,
Circumcision and Hygiene in Geriatric Patients,
J Am Geriatric Soc. 1999; 47: 115.
References
1. C.M. Lannon et al.,
Circumcision Policy Statement of the AAP Task Force on Circumcision (March 1999)
Pediatrics 1999; 103(3):686-693.
 
Back to the top
To access an on-site
version of the article, see here.
See also the Section
Policy Statement from Pediatric
Societies.
  Back to the Main Index